IUPAC-NIST Solubility Database
NIST Standard Reference Database 106


Glass Ball as Bullet Solubility System: 1-Butanol with Cyclohexane and Water

Components:
   (1) Water; H2O; [7732-18-5]  NIST Chemistry WebBook for detail
   (2) 1-Butanol (n-butanol, butyl alcohol, n-butyl alcohol); C4H10O; [71-36-3]  NIST Chemistry WebBook for detail
   (3) Cyclohexane; C6H12; [110-82-7]  NIST Chemistry WebBook for detail

Evaluator:
   A. Skrzecz, Institute of Physical Chemistry, Polish Academy of Sciences, Warsaw, Poland (1995.09)

Critical Evaluation:

      A survey of reported compositions along the saturation curve (sat), and compositions of coexisting phases in equilibrium (eq.) for the system 1-butanol-cyclohexane-water is given in Table 73.

Saturation curve
   The ternary system 1-butanol-cyclohexane-water forms a miscibility gap of type 2. The system was studied by titration method at 298.2 K in both cases. Two binary systems, cyclohexane-water and 1-butanol-water, form miscibility gaps. The data of these binary systems were compiled and critically evaluated in previously published SDS volumes, Refs. 3 and 4, respectively. The recommended values of mutual solubility at 298 K are: for cyclohexane-water system x"2=1.2·10–5 and x'3=3.7·10–4,3 and for 1-butanol-water system x'1=0.488 and x"1=0.0191.4 Letcher et al.2 reported ternary data and the mutual solubility of the binary systems. The end points of the saturation curve were reported to be x2=0.999 and pure water which is inconsistent with recommended values but within the accuracy of experimental measurements (0.001 mole fraction) stated by the authors. Binary solubility data of the 1-butanol-water system reported in Ref. 2 as x1=0.488 and x1=0.019 were consistent with the “best values” reported in the critical evaluation. Ref. 3 Plackov and Stern1 reported the solubility of 1-butanol in water to be x"1=0.0187. This result is also consistent with recommended data. These experimental data are consistent with one another. Compositions of the water-rich phase of the ternary system, Refs. 1 and 2, were reported as binary 1-butanol-water mixtures; the analytical methods used could not detect cyclohexane. Therefore the water-rich branch cannot be evaluated. Phase equilibrium data were included with the description of the saturation curve of the organic-rich phase and data at 298.2 K were described by the equation:
x1=0.695 74+0.046 03 ln(x2)–0.440 62x2–0.259 44x22.
   The model applies to the region 0.02<x2<0.99. The parameters were calculated by the least-squares method. The standard error of estimate was 0.0043. The points on the saturation curve calculated by the above equation for selected concentrations of cyclohexane in the mixture are presented in Table 74 and in Figure 39 as a calculated binodal curve (solid line).

Phases in equilibrium
   Compositions of coexisting phases in equilibrium for the ternary system 1-butanol-cyclohexane-water were reported in two references at 298.2 K by similar experimental procedures. First equilibrium was reached, then the phases were separated and the composition of each was determined. Compositions of the water-rich phase in equilibrium were reported as binary 1-butanol-water mixtures; the analytical methods could not detect cyclohexane. The tie lines cover the whole area of the miscibility gap and they are consistent within each data set. Distribution of 1-butanol differs between data sets with Letcher et al.2 reporting lower concentrations of alcohol in the water-rich phase than the data of Plackov and Stern.1 The data become similar only in the area of low cyclohexane concentrations (x'2<0.090 in the organic-rich phase). Both data sets are treated as tentative. All experimental data points at 298.2 K are shown in Figure 39 .

Experimental Data:   (Notes on the Nomenclature)

TABLE 73. Summary of experimental data for the system 1-butanol-cyclohexane-water
AuthorT/KDataTypeReference
Plackov and Stern, 1990298sat. (13), eq. (6)1
Letcher et al., 1991298sat. (14), eq. (5)2
TABLE 74. Calculated compositions along the saturation curve at 298.2 K. (organic-rich phase)
T/KMole Fraction x1Mole Fraction x2
298.20.4880.000 Ref. 4
298.20.50680.0200
298.20.52950.0400
298.20.53890.0600
298.20.54260.0800
298.20.54310.1000
298.20.54150.1200
298.20.53850.1400
298.20.53420.1600
298.20.52910.1800
298.20.52320.2000
298.20.51660.2200
298.20.50940.2400
298.20.50160.2600
298.20.49340.2800
298.20.48480.3000
298.20.47570.3200
298.20.46630.3400
298.20.45650.3600
298.20.44630.3800
298.20.43580.4000
298.20.42500.4200
298.20.41390.4400
298.20.40240.4600
298.20.39070.4800
298.20.37870.5000
298.20.36640.5200
298.20.35380.5400
298.20.34090.5600
298.20.32780.5800
298.20.31450.6000
298.20.30080.6200
298.20.28690.6400
298.20.27280.6600
298.20.25840.6800
298.20.24380.7000
298.20.22890.7200
298.20.21380.7400
298.20.19840.7600
298.20.18280.7800
298.20.16690.8000
298.20.15080.8200
298.20.13450.8400
298.20.11800.8600
298.20.10120.8800
298.20.08420.9000
298.20.06690.9200
298.20.04950.9400
298.20.03180.9600
298.20.01380.9800
298.20.00480.9900
298.20.00000.99963 Ref. 3
298.20.00000.000012 Ref. 3
298.20.01910.0000 Ref. 4
View Figure 1 for this Evaluation

Notes:
Table 73  Number of experimental points in parentheses.

References: (Click a link to see its experimental data associated with the reference)

   1  Plackov, D.; Stern, I, Fluid. Phase Equilib. 57, 327 (1990).
   2  Letcher, T.M.; Siswana, P.; Radloff, S.E., S. Afr. J. Chem. 44, 118 (1991).
   3  Shaw, D.G., ed., Solubility Data Series, Vol. 37, Hydrocarbons with Water and Seawater, Part I: Hydrocarbons C5 to C7 (Pergamon, New York, 1989).
   4  Barton, A.F. M., ed., Solubility Data Series, Vol. 15, Alcohols with Water (Pergamon, New York 1984).